The Platypus GravityWorks system allows you to put very silty water into your dirty bag. Field maintenance is also easy. For example, the MSR Guardian and the Grayl Ultralight Purifier Bottle will take ickies like norovirus out of your water but the Guardian is a bit of a bear to use in a sink, and you have to be much more careful about cross-contamination using the Grayl by the side of a stream. Thank you for supporting our work and mission of outdoor coverage for every body! We were able to get the TrailShot out of the box and know how to use it immediately. Not sure I'm arriving at all the same conclusions, but it may be due to the fact I don't completely understand the Sawyer products. While it cant handle viruses the small and lightweight TrailShot uses similar hollow fiber filter technology as the Guardian and is suitable for removing bacteria, protozoa and particulates from almost any moving water source MSR advises against filtering from stagnant water. Whether it's living on the road or living out of a backpack, traveling and just being in the outdoors is second nature to me. Ive got two MSR pump-types, several Sawyer Minis, and now a BeFree. Theyre too inconvenient and the flow rate is too slow. Thats it. Gravity filter systems are a given. So far the 1.0L bottle has held up fine to moderate bushwhacking and climbing over many downed trees and through overgrown trails. Reproduction without permission is prohibited. Don't miss the latest news and discussion. A hardcore pump filter like the MSR Guardian Purifier with medical grade hollow fiber technology and virus protection might be the right choice for your next Andean alpine expedition; while a simple handheld squeeze filter like the MSR TrailShot is perfect for trail running and ultra light backpacking. It really is quite good at doing what it was designed to do, which is filter protozoans and bacteria for one person on the go. The MSR Trailshot Water Filter is a highly portable backcountry water filter that has a water fountain spout so you can drink on the go without having to carry a water bottle. We inspire and inform through original bikepacking routes, stories, and coverage of the gear, news, and events that make our community thrive. I dont believe this product is really designed for hikers or for people who need to filter 2-3 liters at a time. The Bikepacking Journal is our biannual printed publication. You wouldnt want to filter and then have leftover nasties still waiting for you on your bottles lip. We create reader-supported, objective gear reviews independently selected by our editors. He would fill the bottle, screw on the cap/filter and immediately be able to drink from the spout with a large flow rate. We know, we know, weve mentioned it a bunch, and purifiers are more expensive but if you use your run-of-the-mill backpacking water filter in countries where the sewage systems arent the best, youll still potentially be exposing yourself to viruses. Pay close attention to your needs while youre looking at weight, to make sure you have the right tool for your adventure. So after a few extra sturdy shakes the TrailShot is back to a steady flow, albeit still not as great as it was out of the box. Still, a little forethought and care or using it as an inline filter as a part of a hydration pack or gravity filter system, as we talked about solve both of these issues, so the Sawyer Squeeze is still the best backpacking water filter for most folks headed outside. Though the form is different, the TrailShot is basically a pump filter. The MSR TrailShot filter is designed to make drinking water out on the trail less of a game of Russian roulette, all without taking up much room in your pack or jersey. All that extra junk is probably going to clog your filter, making it less efficient at best, or less effective at worse. For a longer trip Id carry an extra 0.6L bottle as a backup, or maybe a Hydropak instead of a 1.0L smartwater bottle for storage. #1 I saw the recent post about the MSR Guardian (Super expensive water filter). No duplication of photos, maps, or text without permission. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. MSR TrailShot Pocket-Sized water filter lets you refill your reservoir or drink directly from the source without lying in the dirt. Having purchased the BeFree to replace my Sawyer Squeeze and having used for several months now, the need to clean the BeFree while hiking is minimal/non-existent compared to the need to backwash the Sawyer Squeeze. The Sawyer Squeezes absolute 0.1-micron hollow fibers remove protozoa, bacteria, and cysts from the water it filters. Success, at last. Do people fill their bottle with dirty water, attach the Sawyer and and drink directly? I also own the Sawyer Mini and Squeeze. For reference though because of circumstances i was drinking like 4-5 liters a day, plus cooking water, plus the two others water needs. For a rigid bottle, drill a small hole, cover with duct tape and put a slit in the tape. Im literally standing in the water for hours at a time, so it seems silly to lug around bottles of the stuff or a hydration pack. Customer reviews are consistently high right around 4.5 out of 5 stars on Amazon, REI, and Backcountry although theyre less exuberant than we were expecting. If the water is suspect, I like to dry the outside of the bottle on my shirt before drinking. If you do have issues, though, aBackcountryreviewer reports that MSRs customer service is on point and ready to help. Intel was limited and we had no idea where wed find water, nor how often. Offering Full review. Others agree with Switchback Travel, suggesting that this is not a filter for groups the Platypus GravityWorks is a much better water filtration system if youve got a lot of people. Occupying the #1 slot at both Outdoor Gear Lab and Switchback Travel, thePlatypus GravityWorks 4Linvolves the least amount of work among all the water filtration systems we tested. Sawyer Mini vs MSR TrailShot Water Filter The Emporium Outdoors 29.8K subscribers Subscribe 10K views 5 years ago Sawyer Mini vs MSR TrailShot Water Filter After running with the Sawyer water. Numerous waterborne viruses cause the stomach flu, which can knock you out of commission for days at a time so drop that extra cash and make sure youre covered. The strong flow rate of the Katadyn BeFree filter. And those tests cost most than most filters. With a route such as our trans-Cuba where the hydration requirements were high and the water sources are variable, the TrailShot was adequate. For removing viruses, the upgrade-pick MSR Guardianfilters out viruses and cleans itself with the press of a hand-pump. The flow rate on the Squeeze is noticeably higher than the Mini or Micro Squeeze. Mar 23, 2022 #1 My MSR did not survive winter storage. Copyright 2023 Treeline Review LLC. For shorter overnight trips, we recommend going with the Katadyn BeFree. I'm considering the MSR TrailShot Microfilter 2019 Water Filter . Looking at MSRs site it seems that unlike their other filters TrailShot does not remove or reduce tastes, odors, some chemicals, pesticides or herbicides since there is no carbon. If its your bottles or filter that tastes gross usually like plastic run some tap water with either lemon or lime juice through them before heading out. The Ecologically Pure Water from a Pristine Mountain River did not look very clean to me, you know. At a price just south of USD $9, it's doubtless overpriced but still well worth it for any Squeeze users. The Steripen easily fits in your hand. MSR HyperFlow Microfilter. I purchased a Sawyer Squeeze when they first came out and only used it twice. Sawyer Mini wins the game with a customer satisfaction rate of 81%, while Sawyer Squeeze has the satisfaction rate of 78%. He also paired it with a Cnoc water container with BeFree threads, bypassing the water bag that comes with the filter. Going to take it out on a 4 day trip at the end of the month, but I AM taking my Sawyer mini with me as a backup. All you do is fill the Dirty bag, hang it higher than the Clean bag, and open up the line to send a liter per minute into the Clean bag below. Todds comments about the dry filter are correct it takes 10 to 20 minutes for the filter to begin waking up and want to filter again after it has been completely dried. The Mini is best suited for shorter trips in areas with particular pristine water, like the Sierra. Streams, lakes, puddles, rivers, even sinks weve filtered from all sorts of sources, and some filters are better at some sources than others. 99.9 or 99.99% is good enough? REIreviewers warn the hang grommets fall apart. You can also put a cap on it so it doesnt leak water all over your other gear. While you can use it for refilling water bottles for hiking, I think a BeFree 3L, BeFree 1L, Sawyer Squeeze and better solutions for hikers because you can filter more water with less effort and they include the ability to transport water if you dont need to use it right away. Maybe not the ideal solution for ultralight bikepacking. This may be true, but does not inspire confidence. On relatively similar trips in Africa we brought both the Sawyer Squeeze filter as well as a rechargeable Steripen the idea was to filter particulates and bacteria, then zap viruses and other microscopic organisms that the 0.2 micron Sawyer filter couldn't remove. Originally I chose the Trailshot because it made more sense to me. MSR TrailShot. You decide. The best thing about it is that it is entirely self contained, meaning no bottles to fill with contaminated water. Put dirty water into the bladder. NEW! To backflush the Trail Shot you simply remove the hose and force the water back out the hole in the bottom. Which Water Filter do you buy - The Sawyer or the MSR Trailshot? MSR sent us their then yet to be released TrailShot and we tossed it in a bag with very little information and no backup come hell or no water. Reproduction without permission is prohibited. The hose the the trail shot was undesirable for me. Thanks for the information about getting the filter wet before heading out in order to give it time to absorb water and unclog. I will say though that the trailshot definitely has a place, for shorter trips, trail running, or if you only have to filter water for yourself i think that its a good choice. For the price and the effectiveness, the Katadyn Steripen Ultra is a worthy buy. Its generally considered safe to only use a filter in North America where viruses are uncommon in the backcountry. Given its size, weight, and price, the TrailShot seems like the perfect system for jaunts where there are plenty of water sources to dip into. On average, Gin and I consumed about 6-8 liters per day. Type: Electro adsorption and activated carbon. Photo by Liz Thomas. Enter the MSR TrailShot. $49.95 Used Value: $29.97 Sale Value: $44.96 Features & Specs 20 Reviews Tweet Share Submit From ultralight backpacking trips to epic mountain bike rides, the MSR TrailShot Microfilter provides ultra-compact purification, allowing you to drink directly from streams and lakes on the trail. Drops and freezing temperatures are not your friends. The last thing you want is to get ready for your next trip and find that molds grown in your filter (which has definitely never happened to us, not even once, so many questions, why are you asking). Cant be used in gravity mode from what I see. GearLab is founded on the principle of honest, objective, reviews. As mentioned, the flow rate was reduced to a trickle at some point, albeit partially due to ignorance on our part. Carying syringe is a pain, squeezing bags isnt fun. Since then I got the original sawyer squeeze and use the bags for short solo trips and a gravity bag for longer trips with multiple people which makes things so much easier, just fill and forget. Id caution you against touching your mouth to the drink spout because there is the potential for of cross-contamination if the drink spout gets wet from the hose or pre-filter when the unit is folded up and stuffed in a pocket. (Watch your gasket, though this o-shaped ring makes a seal with the bladder or bottle, and is prone to falling out of the filter if youre not careful. But if youre obsessed with moving as fast as possible and only carrying what you need, Id encourage you try the MSR TrailShot Water Filter. This certainly helped, but it never seemed to have the virulent flow that it did out of the box. It comes with a case (shown here) for protection, though many adventurers opt not to carry it in the field. The third time using this filter in my mountain trip, the filter slipped out of the body. Once my trip is done, I will share my experience back here with everyone. The Sawyer Squeeze filtration system offers amazing versatility for all sorts of adventures. I have both of these and will say the MSR Trail shot only got used once and has been sitting in my garage since. We like the Platypus GravityWorks, which can filter four liters in four minutes with minimal fuss. Though you can filter from the dirty bags the Squeeze comes with into a clean filtered water bottle if you like, we prefer to drink straight through the sports top, getting our fix instantly.
School Backpacks In Bulk, Zara Home Linen Curtains, Calves For Sale In Hillcrest, Matching Swimwear For Family, Choc Chip Animation Studios, 16gb Noobs With Raspbian Microsd Card, Sram Matchmaker Vs Matchmaker X, Oil And Gas Jobs Western Australia,
